Farm Diecast

Identifying vintage ERTL farm toys

Many early ERTL farm toys, especially John Deere models, have no model number, and many have lost their box. Identify them by casting, wheels, decals, box text and ink date stamp. Where sources disagree, this guide says so. The ERTL catalog lookup looks up stock numbers and reads date codes.

Who made it

Several Midwest firms made toys of the same tractors in the same years, and sellers often call them all ERTL. Settle the maker first.

ERTL 1945–
Fred ERTL Sr. cast the first toys in his Dubuque, Iowa, basement from melted aircraft aluminum. The company moved into its Dyersville plant in July 1959.
Eska 1945–1986
Formed in late 1945 to distribute ERTL toys to farm equipment dealers. ERTL made the tractors and Eska, later Carter, made the implements. Eska also made pedal tractors. Vossler says ERTL and Eska split in late 1959 and ERTL took over Eska's licenses in 1960 and 1961. Farm Tractor Collectibles dates ERTL's buyout of Eska to 1963.
Carter Tru-Scale 1950–1971
Rockford, Illinois. Carter built many of the stamped-steel implements sold as Eska, took over Eska's manufacturing in 1951 and sold its own Tru-Scale line from 1950. Victor Comptometer, ERTL's parent, bought it in January 1971.
Scale Models 1977–
Founded by Joseph L. ERTL, Fred's son, who had started Dyersville Die Casting in 1970. Sources give both 1977 and 1978 for its start. Its collectors' guide says the castings carry the initials J.L.E. to deter copies. It also reused old Hubley tooling.
Hubley to 1970s
Cast Ford tractors in 1:12 (961, 4000, 6000) and a 1:10 Ford with an H on the front. ERTL's first Ford, the 1965 4000, was also 1:12.
Arcade to 1945
Cast-iron toys. Arcade stopped making toys after World War II, and ERTL bought its leftover wheels, so some early ERTL John Deere A tractors roll on wheels marked Arcade.
Slik and Product Miniature 1940s–1960s
Slik made sand-cast aluminum Olivers and small die-cast tractors. Product Miniature made plastic Farmall and Allis-Chalmers tractors and International trucks in the 1950s.

Early ERTL, 1945 to 1950s

  • Among ERTL's first tractors were an Allis-Chalmers WC, a Farmall M and a John Deere A, sand-cast in aluminum with the driver cast in. The John Deere and Farmall drivers wear a flat-top hat; the Allis-Chalmers driver is thicker than Arcade's.
  • John Deere A, first release: cast-aluminum wheels, then rubber tires, with an open flywheel. The second release has a different hat and a web of metal between the air cleaner and the exhaust.
  • John Deere A, 1947 pattern: the flywheel is enclosed, "ERTL Toy" is cast on the base of the steering post and "Made in USA" on the end of the flywheel. It is slightly smaller than 1:16. By 1950 the driver was gone.
  • Early ERTL toys carry no model number on the casting. Collectors call them "430" or "620" after the real tractor.

Dating clues

Who owned ERTL

ERTL's owners by year
OwnerYears
ERTL family1945–1967
Victor Comptometer Corporation1967–1977
Walter Kidde1977–1988
Hanson Industries, which bought Kidde1988

ERTL's 1974 and 1977 trade ads read "Division of Victor Comptometer Corporation", so a box naming Victor was printed in or near those ownership years. A box printed just after a sale can still carry the old name.

Ink date codes

Many ERTL toys from the 1970s to the early 1990s carry a small ink date stamp, usually underneath. The stamp gives only the year's last digit, so the model's production years give the decade. Read an ERTL date code with the decoder.

Dated and engraved editions

  • Show and club editions often carry a full date. The Toy Farmer Farmall 560 for the first National Farm Toy Show is dated 11-1-78, and a second issue 3-1-79.
  • Each dealer got one IH 3588 First Edition for a promotional display; a variation has the words ground off. The IH 5288 has a version engraved "FIRST EDITION, KC, 9-81" on the frame and the IH 5088 one engraved "SPECIAL EDITION 12-81". Each also exists without the engraving.
  • ERTL's International Harvester construction toys changed from yellow to light brown in 1981 (the payhauler in 1982). A limited number of yellow 412B scrapers were made.
  • The John Deere 7520 switched from water-transfer decals to stickers on its 1975 version, the earliest dated switch in these sources.

Stock number reuse and suffixes

The ERTL catalog lookup covers the dealer catalogs (1982, and 1987 onward with gaps) and stock numbers from 1957 to 1979 in Raymond Crilley's 1979 directory.

  • ERTL reused numbers. 609 was a White Oliver 1855 in 1975 and a Case IH planter by 1989; 437 was an IH 404 in the 1960s and a Farmall F-20 by 1989. A number alone never identifies a toy.
  • One number can also cover several versions of one toy: 530 was both the John Deere 3010 of 1961 and the 3020 of 1964.
  • By 1987 a two-letter suffix follows the number. In the retail catalogs on file the second letter changes over the years (1007FO in 1990, 1007FP in 1993, 1007FR in 1994, 1007FN in 1997), so it looks like a revision letter.
  • PA (a Toy Farmer edition), TA and DA (collector and anniversary editions) each appear on a single example outside the retail catalogs; one anniversary piece carries DO. No known ERTL document defines the letters, so read this as a pattern only.

Versions

ERTL changed castings, wheels and decals during a toy's run without changing its name. Each version lists how to spot it, its sources, and whether they agree.

John Deere 3010, 3020, 4010 and 40201:16

ERTL's New Generation John Deere carried no model number, so collectors name it 3010, 3020, 4010 or 4020 by its casting. There are three castings; both diesel castings come with several wheel combinations. Stock numbers 530, 541, 547, 553.

  1. Gas engine casting 1961 Two or more sources

    Generator; three levers on the top left of the dash and one on the top right; all four wheels die-cast; three-point hitch.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Farm Tractor Collectibles 1998 : Farm Tractor Collectibles (MBI, 1998)

  2. Diesel casting with generator 1964 Two or more sources

    Two short fuel filters on the left side of the engine. Rims die-cast or plastic in several front and rear combinations. Only the earliest have the three-point hitch; ERTL dropped it from all versions in early 1964.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Farm Tractor Collectibles 1998 : Farm Tractor Collectibles (MBI, 1998)

  3. Diesel casting with alternator 1965–1968 Sources disagree

    Alternator instead of generator and longer fuel filters; one lever on each side of the dash top. Plastic rims. Later a wide front axle (547) and an attached roll-over frame (553).

    Crilley's text dates this casting to 1967; his directory lists versions from 1965 to 1968.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Farm Tractor Collectibles 1998 : Farm Tractor Collectibles (MBI, 1998)

John Deere 75201:16

ERTL's first four-wheel-drive John Deere toy, introduced in 1972 with the real tractor. Stock number 510.

  1. First version 1972 One source

    One-piece solid plastic air intake. Water-transfer decals.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke on the John Deere 7520, The Toy Tractor Times

  2. Second version One source

    Two-piece air intake after about a year of production. Water-transfer decals.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke on the John Deere 7520, The Toy Tractor Times

  3. Third version One source

    A large rivet across the inside back of the cab. The most common 7520.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke on the John Deere 7520, The Toy Tractor Times

  4. One-hole version 1975 Two or more sources

    No air intake, only the exhaust stack, and sticker decals instead of water-transfer decals. The rarest of the four.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke on the John Deere 7520, The Toy Tractor Times ; Deere 1990 : The Toy and the Real McCoy (Deere & Company, 1990)

John Deere 630 (also called 730)1:16

The 30 series toy has fenders and a rubber exhaust. It carried no model number. Stock number 10.

  1. With three-point hitch 1958 Two or more sources

    Three-point hitch on the rear.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Deere 1990 : The Toy and the Real McCoy (Deere & Company, 1990) ; Farm Tractor Collectibles 1998 : Farm Tractor Collectibles (MBI, 1998)

  2. Without three-point hitch 1959 Sources disagree

    No three-point hitch; with or without a muffler. One version has no exhaust stack.

    Crilley names this toy a 630 and says some collectors call it a 730; Deere's own book calls it the 730.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Deere 1990 : The Toy and the Real McCoy (Deere & Company, 1990)

John Deere 430 utility1:16

Wide front axle with steering front wheels. Stock number 20.

  1. With three-point hitch 1958 Two or more sources

    Three-point hitch on the rear.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Deere 1990 : The Toy and the Real McCoy (Deere & Company, 1990)

  2. Without three-point hitch 1962 Two or more sources

    No three-point hitch; sold through stores other than dealers.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Farm Tractor Collectibles 1998 : Farm Tractor Collectibles (MBI, 1998)

Farmall 5601:16

Sold first under the Eska name, then as ERTL, in many versions. Stock numbers 408, 409, 460.

  1. Eska-labeled 560 1950s Sources disagree

    450-type front wheels, two-point hitch and belt pulley. Red and white.

    Zarse labels this toy Eska; Vossler says Eska did not make tractors.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

  2. ERTL, two-point hitch 1957 Sources disagree

    Two-point hitch, with or without belt pulley. Underneath: a smooth rear housing, or a solid drawbar cut off.

    Crilley lists a 1957 ERTL 560 with a fast hitch; Zarse dates the two-point-hitch ERTL 560 to the 1960s.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

  3. ERTL, standard drawbar 1960s One source

    Solid drawbar, no two-point hitch, no belt pulley; plastic front rims.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

  4. White wheels, duals and cab 1967–1968 Sources disagree

    White wheels (408), white dual rear wheels (460), and a cab adapted from a later tractor (409, 1968).

    Crilley dates these to 1967 and 1968; Zarse lists the duals and cab versions under the 1970s.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

  5. 1970s, plastic grille 1972 Two or more sources

    Plastic rims and plastic grille; Crilley lists a 1972 version with no 560 decals or exhaust.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

Farmall 560, Toy Farmer and National Farm Toy Show editions1:16

Recast from the ERTL 560 for The Toy Farmer and the first National Farm Toy Show in Dyersville.

On Farm Diecast: McCormick Farmall 560 ; McCormick Farmall 560 w/Duals

  1. First issue 1978 Two or more sources

    Dated 11-1-78 (Crilley prints 1/11/78); wide front axle and different wheels; 500 made.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984) ; Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  2. Second issue 1979 Two or more sources

    Dated 3-1-79; dual rear wheels and wide front axle; 500 more made.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984) ; Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

International 5441:16

Red narrow front made from 1969 to 1983, plus wide front, duals, loader and yellow industrial versions. Stock numbers 414, 415, 416, 417, 418, 421.

  1. Earliest narrow front 1969 One source

    IH cream plastic rims, narrow rubber rear tires, grooved plastic front tires, thin string loop.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke, The Uncommon Versions of a Common Tractor Part II, The Toy Tractor Times

  2. Thicker string loop One source

    A thicker string loop; some of this series have a rivet under the dash.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke, The Uncommon Versions of a Common Tractor Part II, The Toy Tractor Times

  3. Late 1970s late 1970s One source

    Front tires with diamonds on the sidewalls; string loop dropped; some rims very light tan.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke, The Uncommon Versions of a Common Tractor Part II, The Toy Tractor Times

  4. Plastic rear tires 1981 One source

    One-inch-wide plastic rear tires like the 3088's; the hole in the oil pan closed in 1981 or 1982.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke, The Uncommon Versions of a Common Tractor Part II, The Toy Tractor Times

  5. Yellow industrial 1969–1970 Two or more sources

    Yellow, wide front (416) or narrow front with loader (421); some narrow-front yellow 544s have no loader. ERTL literature shows 2644 on the side, but production toys carry no number. The loader version has a metal open-end steering wheel.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke, The Uncommon Versions of a Common Tractor Part II, The Toy Tractor Times ; Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984) ; Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  6. Front spindles One source

    Large or small front spindles.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

International 15861:16

Cab and dual rear wheels; still being updated in 1993. Stock number 463.

  1. First version 1977 Sources disagree

    56-66 series front tires; front wheels with a red or a black center inside.

    Crilley lists the 1586 under 1976; Harke gives 1977.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke on the International 1586, The Toy Tractor Times ; Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

  2. Second version One source

    14L-16A wheels.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke on the International 1586, The Toy Tractor Times

  3. Third version One source

    Hard plastic tires.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke on the International 1586, The Toy Tractor Times

  4. Toy store version 1985 One source

    Single rear wheels; no cab door, taillight, slow-moving-vehicle sign or cab roof decal. Loader added in 1989; engine recast for loader mounts in 1990; rear tires from rubber to plastic in 1991; loader bucket from black to red in 1993.

    Sources: Harke, Toy Tractor Times : Doug Harke on the International 1586, The Toy Tractor Times

Farmall 8061:16

Wide front, working steering. Stock number 435.

  1. Round fenders 1964 Two or more sources

    Round fenders, die-cast rear wheels, plastic fronts.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

  2. Flat fenders 1965 One source

    Flat fenders.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  3. Rear rims One source

    Die-cast or plastic rear rims.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

Farmall and International 4041:16

Utility with three-point hitch from about 1961, and a row crop. Stock number 437.

  1. Row crop, red wheels 1964 One source

    Red wheels; Crilley lists no three-point hitch on the row crop.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  2. Row crop, white wheels 1967 One source

    White wheels.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  3. Rim and hitch variations One source

    Die-cast rims, plastic front rims with die-cast rears, or all plastic; red or white rims; with and without a three-point hitch.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

International 915 combine1:16

Four versions, in production order.

  1. First 1960s One source

    Metal reel with chain drive; silver steering column.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

  2. Second 1960s One source

    Plastic reel; silver steering column; knobby or smooth rear tires.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

  3. Third 1970s One source

    Plastic reel; red steering column; dual exhaust stacks.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

  4. Fourth 1970s One source

    Dual exhaust stacks left off.

    Sources: Zarse 1984 : Robert Zarse, A Guide to McCormick and International Toys (1984)

Ford 4000, 4400 and 46001:12

ERTL's first Ford, in the larger 1:12 scale Hubley had used. Stock numbers 805, A-805.

  1. Sectional grille 1965 One source

    Two-piece sectional grille; three-point hitch; wide front.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  2. One-piece grille 1968 One source

    One-piece grille, otherwise almost the same.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  3. 4400 Industrial 1972 One source

    Yellow; otherwise the same as the 1968 4000.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  4. 4600 1976 One source

    Fenders change from round to flat.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

Ford 8000, 8600 and 96001:12

The larger ERTL Ford, from 1968. Stock numbers 800, A-800, A-821.

  1. 8000, small decals 1968 One source

    Three-point hitch; 'Ford' and '8000' small on the side decal.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  2. 8000, large decals 1970 One source

    Decal changed to a large '8000'; the three-point hitch is left off some.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  3. 8600 and 9600 1973–1974 Sources disagree

    Renumbered with the real tractors; no three-point hitch. The 9600 adds a cab and duals.

    Crilley lists the 8600 without a three-point hitch; several collectors report early 8600s with one.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

Allis-Chalmers D-171:16

ERTL's first Allis-Chalmers in about fifteen years, with working steering. Stock number 104.

  1. Series I 1960 One source

    Orange wheels; black trim around the grille; headlights.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  2. Series II 1961 One source

    Off-white wheels; lighter grille decal and side trim.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  3. Series III 1964 Sources disagree

    No headlights; the decal runs nearly the length of the hood.

    Crilley describes three series; Farm Tractor Collectibles says the toy went through four logo revisions in five years.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Farm Tractor Collectibles 1998 : Farm Tractor Collectibles (MBI, 1998)

Allis-Chalmers 190 and 190XT1:16

Wide front; fuel tank behind the seat. Stock number 192.

  1. Metal wheels 1965 One source

    Metal wheels; bars across the grille.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  2. Plastic wheels 1966 One source

    Plastic wheels; bar grille.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  3. 190XT 1969 Sources disagree

    No cross bars on the grille; fender design changed.

    Farm Tractor Collectibles mentions a 1966 grille facelift without describing it; Crilley's 1966 version still has the bar grille.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Farm Tractor Collectibles 1998 : Farm Tractor Collectibles (MBI, 1998)

  4. 190XT Series III Landhandler 1971 One source

    Rollover frame with a canopy; larger flotation tires front and rear. Stock AC-188.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

Minneapolis-Moline G-1000 Vista1:16

ERTL's first 1:16 Minneapolis-Moline since the early 1950s Z. Stock number 17.

  1. Yellow wheels 1968 Sources disagree

    Yellow wheels; G-1000 Vista decal.

    Crilley's text says 1967; his directory and Farm Tractor Collectibles say 1968.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979) ; Farm Tractor Collectibles 1998 : Farm Tractor Collectibles (MBI, 1998)

  2. White wheels 1972 One source

    White wheels; no G-1000 Vista decal.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

Case 1070 Agri King1:16

Removable cab with built-in roll-over frame. Stock numbers 200, 210.

  1. Agri King 1969 One source

    Cab; single (200) or dual (210) rear wheels.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  2. Demonstrator 1970 One source

    Black trim with a beige cab; duals.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

  3. Black Knight 1971 One source

    More black paint and gold trim; 451 Cubes decal.

    Sources: Crilley 1979 : Raymond E. Crilley, Collecting Model Farm Toys of the World (1979)

Reproductions, reissues and repaints

  • New Hubley and Arcade toys have been cast from the old molds and sold as originals. Product Miniature plastic toys, including the Farmall M and Allis-Chalmers WD, have been reissued from the original tooling, so reissues are hard to tell from originals.
  • The 1985 40th anniversary John Deere A is stamped "ERTL 1945-1985" and is a new model, not a reproduction of the 1945 toy.
  • Restorers sell reproduction decals and fit new axles and rivets, so new-looking decals or rivets are a reason to look closer. Restoring a toy usually lowers its value to collectors.

Sources

The Internet Archive lends these books to anyone with a free account. Farm Diecast may earn a commission on qualifying Amazon purchases. Affiliate disclosure